Op-ed: I'm A
Trans Man Who Doesn't 'Pass' — And You Shouldn't Either
To paraphrase
Janet Mock: Trans people aren't 'passing' as men or women. We're being.
BY Aiden
James Kosciesza
May 20 2015 6:00 AM ET
Out of all the words in the transgender lexicon,
“passing” is the one I ate most. And that’s no small feat.
In our rapidly evolving digital world, language is
changing faster than ever. Words that seemed to be standard terminology as
little as four years ago are now out of fashion, or even taboo. When I began my
gender transition in 2011, for example, I called myself a “transsexual,” a word
I no longer use because of its implied connection between gender identity and
sexuality. Yet as words like “tranny” slink out of circulation, “passing”
remains frustratingly well-used, even among the trans* community.
The term “passing,” when applied to transgender
people, means being perceived as cisgender while presenting as one’s authentic
gender identity. There’s a lot of power in that. When people meet me and assume
that I am a cisgender man, I am afforded the privilege of choosing whether I
disclose my transgender identity, and when. Many trans* folks pursue this power
through clothing choices, hormones, surgery, voice training, or even etiquette
lessons, and I’m all for that.
For many of us, the goal of transition is equally
balanced between feeling comfortable in our own skin and showing the world who
we really are. The problem is that when trans* people use the word “passing”
for what we’ve achieved, it diminishes everything that we’re fighting for.
To “pass” for something immediately connotes
deception and untruth. Think of plagiarists passing off someone else’s work as
their own, a look-alike cousin who could easily pass for his relative, or the
mocking lines of Shakespeare’s Portia in Merchant of Venice: “God made him, and
therefore let him pass for a man.”
To look at trans* people expressing their authentic
selves and say that they “pass” for men or women is to diminish their identity
by implying that it’s an act. Telling a trans* woman that she “passes” is like
saying “You’re not a real woman, but good job faking it.”
If that sounds like a slap in the face, well — it
is. Yet both transgender people and their allies continue to use this term,
despite prominent advocates like Janet Mock speaking out against it. Even
articles that call out the term for being controversial and negative will turn
around and use it throughout. The problem is that despite the terrible word we
use for it, the concept of “passing” is very real, and creates a hierarchy of
privilege that can’t be ignored.
We have to talk about the divide between trans*
people who have the privilege of choosing disclosure and those who don’t. It’s
a divide as stark as any racial barrier, and erasing the conversation about
that difference would be a step backward. But we need to change the words that
we use, because the term “passing” perpetuates harmful stereotypes that cast
trans* people as imposters.
The idea that transgender people are inherently
deceptive is not only insulting, it’s dangerous. Perhaps the most famous example
of this danger is the case of Gwen Araujo, who was killed after men who had
consensual sexual relations with her discovered that she had “male” genitalia.
The murderers mounted the “trans panic” defense in court, claiming that this
“crime of passion ... did not merit a charge of first degree murder.” And it
worked. The men were convicted only of second-degree murder. Although Araujo’s
case may be the most famous, it’s far from the only instance of trans* women
being attacked by cisgender men who claim they were deceived.
This leaves trans* people stuck in the middle of an
impossible divide: If we are easily, visibly identifiable as transgender, we
may be insulted, ridiculed, denied jobs or housing, harassed, attacked, or
killed. But if we are not so easily picked out of the crowd, we risk an even
more vitriolic reaction if we are “discovered” — now we’re not only trans*,
we’re liars too.
At the heart of this problem is the word “passing”
itself. Language has power. When people tell us — or worse, when we tell
ourselves — that we’re only “passing” as men or women, that our identities are
a sham or a mask meant to trick the rest of the world, the narrative of
deception takes hold. “Trans panic” murders are the most horrifying consequence
of this narrative, but it also seeps into everyday life in subtle ways.
This narrative of deception remains a part of
public policy, even though transgender people are gaining acceptance and
visibility like never before. I came face-to-face with this stereotype the last
time I donated blood through the American Red Cross. The volunteers themselves
were very kind and helpful, but when I explained that I am transgender, the Red
Cross computer system forced the volunteers to go through the entire blood
donation questionnaire with me out loud, in person. Normally these questions
would be completed by the donor alone, through the computer, which both
increases privacy and allows the volunteers to take donations more efficiently.
My volunteer was flummoxed. “I’ve never seen this
before,” she told me apologetically. “I don’t know why it’s making you answer
all of this out loud!”
I knew why. “Because trans* people are inherently
deceptive,” I said with heavy irony. It was humiliating to be treated that way
— as if my gender identity, which I had just voluntarily disclosed, meant that
I couldn’t be trusted to answer the questions honestly.
The volunteer missed my ironic tone. She turned to
me with a concerned, albeit hesitant look. “Oh ... Is that true?”
If I’d answered yes, I’m sure she would have
believed me.
This is the stigma that we’re fighting. Transgender
people and our allies must not buy into the idea that we are liars, that we’re
putting one over on the world, that we can’t be trusted. To paraphrase Janet
Mock, we’re not “passing.” We’re being.
Trans* people need a new word to replace “passing.”
I prefer "being recognized."
When I’m recognized as male, it means that the
people around me can see who I truly am — thanks in part to the hormones,
clothing, name, and pronouns I've chosen. Being recognized still acknowledges
that work on my part and the changes I've made to align my gender presentation
with my internal gender identity, but it also leaves the power to define that
identity in my own hands. I have always been male, even before I knew it
myself. When others correctly recognize my gender, they’re not being misled.
They are respecting the person I am and the way I choose to show myself to the
world.
Transgender people, please: Stop “passing.” Leave
the outdated, insulting, and dangerous terminology behind, and let the world
recognize your authentic, courageous lives.
AIDEN JAMES KOSCIESZA is a public speaker who
visits universities, hospitals, and organizations to talk about transgender
identities. Follow him on social media (@transaidenjames,
facebook.com/trans.aiden.james) or on the Web at www.aiden-james.com. He lives
in Media, Pa., where he teaches English and awaits his life-changing book deal.
*Editor's Note: The asterisk after the word
"trans" indicates the writer's usage as an umbrella term that aims to
reflect the vast diversity of identities and experiences of individuals who
identify as transgender, transsexual, intersex, nonbinary, and otherwise
gender-nonconforming.













