Bruce Jenner’s Transgender ‘Coming Out': He’s Not Alone,
But Is It In The Genes?
By A. J.
Smuskiewicz | April 23, 2015 | Genetic Literacy Project
“Transgender.” Just
a few years ago, one hardly ever heard or saw that word in the news media. Now,
hardly a week goes by without encountering at least one mainstream news story
on this peculiar subject.
In early 2015,
stories about the gender transition of Bruce Jenner, the 65-year-old former
Olympian, were all over the news. Most of these stories focused on salacious
rumors about Jenner’s transition, paparazzi photographs showing his painted
fingernails or signs of breast growth beneath his shirt, or concerns within the
LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender) community about the “spectacle” of
it all.
It did indeed seem
like an out-of-control media spectacle in the days leading up to Jenner’s
highly anticipated public “coming out” TV extravaganza, marked by appearances
on Good Morning America and capped by a two-hour interview with Diane Sawyer on
ABC’s 20/20 on April 24, 2015.
Jenner revealed personal info about “the
journey, the decisions, the future”; the Kardashian clan was reported to be
worried about how Jenner’s comments might affect the reality-TV family’s
reputation; and the first photo secretly obtained of Jenner wearing a dress was
pasted across the Internet.
One thing I did not
see in any of these breathless stories about Jenner was a serious, scientific
discussion about the possible causes of transgenderism, including genetic
influences.
As a 55-year-old
individual who has struggled with my gender identity for more than 40
years—still without completely resolving the struggle or conflict—I have long
been curious about the causes of transgenderism. My curiosity stands in
contrast to most of my transgender friends—many of whom have fully transitioned
(unlike myself). They generally show no interest in what caused them to be the
way they are, and they tell me that I should stop worrying about causes and
simply accept it and be happy about it. But I can’t do that.
Perhaps it is my
background in science that makes me need to ask, “Why do I have these feminine
feelings? Why do I like to wear women’s clothes? Why do I sometimes live as a
woman, and why do I sometimes want to become fully female?”
Media Incuriosity or Fear?
With the increasing
media attention being given to the T in LGBT, one would think such answers
would be fairly easy to find these days. But that would be an incorrect
assumption. Like my transgender friends, almost all media reports on this
matter simply acknowledge how wonderful it is for transgender people to express
themselves, and how wrong it is for transgender people to be discriminated
against. I agree with those sentiments. But where is the scientific curiosity
about the gender identity issue?
As with
homosexuality, media reports about transgenderism almost never ask “Why?” Why
are some people homosexual or transgendered? Might it be related in some way to
certain experiences while growing up? Is it something in their genes? If so,
what exactly? It is considered politically incorrect—a sign of intolerance and
bigotry—to ask such questions. That’s what I have been told by a number of
people who work in both journalism and science. And whenever I have raised such
questions in LGBT online discussion boards, I have been shot down with angry
comments, such as “There is no such research!” “Stop asking those stupid
questions!” “Who cares anyway?” “What are you, a troll bigot?”
Geez! That kind of
ignorant, willingly blind attitude drives me crazy! (Also driving me crazy is
the way the media lumps together all forms of transgenderism as a single,
monolithic issue. News flash: “Transgender” can mean a wide variety of things.
For example, a transvestite and a transsexual are both transgender, but they
are very different. One enjoys dressing like a woman but considers himself
male; the other actually wants to be a woman and considers himself female. And
there are some people, like me, who are caught somewhere between the two—not
exactly sure which one best applies to us.)
Personally, I tend
to agree with Lady Gaga that LGBT people were “born this way.” I suspect that
certain gene mutations or other congenital factors (such as certain unusual
conditions in the womb) result in tendencies toward various types of
transgenderism or homosexuality. Nevertheless, I still want to know what the
latest science says about this matter. But reports of such science are rarely
encountered in the mass media, such as television or newspapers.
Every now and then,
however, one does hear or see stories about scientific findings regarding LGBT
issues. The best chance of finding these stories is through the use of
carefully targeted Internet searches.
Gay And Transgender Genes?
In 2014, several
media outlets carried reports of an interesting study of 409 pairs of
homosexual brothers. (This study was formally published in the May 2015 issue
of Psychological Medicine.) The researchers found evidence that sexual
orientation in men is influenced by certain single nucleotide polymorphisms
(SNPs) on chromosome 8 and the X chromosome. This study was described by New
Scientist in November 2014 as “the strongest evidence yet that gay people are
born gay.”
But even New
Scientist, though it properly covered the research findings, felt the need to
editorialize: “Ultimately, what causes homosexuality doesn’t matter as much as
the fact that homosexual people exist, and have always existed, in every
society on earth. In the words of the activists: some people are gay. Get over
it.
Is it necessary to
add such aggressive, activist, off-putting commentary to a science story? I
think not. I also think it is wrong for an allegedly scientific publication to
proclaim that a scientific finding on any subject “doesn’t matter.”
Regarding my
personal interest in LGBT matters, Rolling Stone ran a brief, although welcomed,
article in July 2014 titled “The Science of Transgender: Understanding The
Causes of Being Transgender.” Writer Sabrina Rubin Erdely noted:
…a growing
body of research is pointing to biological origins. The 2008 discovery by
Australian researchers of a genetic variation in transgender women—their
receptor gene for the sex hormone testosterone was longer, making it less
efficient at communicating signals—set off speculation that insufficient uptake
of male hormones in utero contributed to a “more feminised brain.” And the
brains of trans people do look different. Recent Spanish imaging studies have
shown that the white matter of untreated trans men look much like those of
biological males, and that the patterns of trans women’s white matter fell about
halfway between those of biological male and female control groups.
Erdely also noted
that the role of genetics in shaping transgender identity remains very much
unknown, noting, “a recent survey of identical twins found that only in 20
percent of cases did both twins turn out transgender, despite having identical
DNA.”
Such media reports
are refreshing, because they at least indicate to the public that science is
trying to figure out a subject that is usually discussed in only political or
social terms. Even if the science is currently too complex for even scientists
to understand—with unknown interactions of genetic and environmental
influences—it is important that writers in the media honestly convey that
information to the public. Why keep it a secret? Any kind of information based
on scientific evidence is always good to share.
LGBT Objections
Unfortunately, some
people in the LGBT community object to studies that investigate the genetic
roots of gender or sexual identity. Perhaps that is why these kinds of studies
get so little coverage in the mainstream media—and maybe also why there are so
few such studies to begin with. Look at some of the seemingly fearful,
who-cares-about-science comments in reaction to a November 2014 Huffington Post
story about the Psychological Medicine gay brothers study:
1. “On the question
of whether being gay is a choice or not, does it matter? Do people really need
to validate their actions and lives in the eyes of others?”
2. “Born this way –
now leave em alone.”
3. “So, are there
genes that cause heterosexuality? I find this entire inquiry strange: Why not
look for genes that affect sexuality, instead of homosexuality? It’s like white
people trying to explain black people by looking for a gene that made them
different/black. (implying that one would be normal and everything else is
deviation from the norm.)”
4. “But…so what? Why
does it matter why a person is gay or not? What possible use could this info
have other than something that I shudder to contemplate?”
Such public comments
are disheartening. Scientific knowledge should always matter—to everyone. And
it should never be feared—for any reason. To quote renowned psychologist and
author Steven Pinker in The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature
quoting Chekhov, “Man will become better when you show him what he is like.”
We need much more
scientific research into the causes—genetic and otherwise—of homosexual and
transgender behaviors, as well as all other forms of human behavior and
sexuality. Why? Because knowledge about human behavior and sexuality is
essential to understanding what being human is all about. And investigating
what it means to be human is one of the noblest quests of science. Then, after
the science, we need honest media reports about this research—free from
political agendas, advocacy, or fear mongering.
In a story about the
Psychological Medicine gay brothers study in February 2014, The Guardian
included insightful comments by Qazi Rahman, a psychologist at King’s College
London:
“This is not
controversial or surprising and is nothing people should worry about. All human
psychological traits are heritable, that is, they have a genetic component,” he
said. “Genetic factors explain 30 to 40% of the variation between people’s
sexual orientation. However, we don’t know where these genetic factors are
located in the genome. So we need to do ‘gene finding’ studies, like this one
by Sanders, Bailey and others, to have a better idea where potential genes for
sexual orientation may lie.”
Rahman rejected the
idea that genetics research could be used to discriminate against people on the
basis of their sexual orientation. “I don’t see how genetics would contribute
more to the persecution, discrimination and stigmatisation of lesbian, gay,
bisexual and transgender people any more than social, cultural or learning
explanations. Historically, the persecution and awful treatment of LGBT groups
has been because politicians, religious leaders and societies have viewed
sexual orientation as ‘choice’ or due to poor upbringing.”
I would go a bit
further, by offering my own version of FDR’s famous proclamation: “…let me
assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear of science
itself.”
A. J. Smuskiewicz is
a freelance writer specializing in science and medicine, including issues of
human sexuality and gender. He can be contacted at: ajsmuskie@gmail.com.