Sunday, December 27, 2015

Transletter

Social Inclusion: Bengal Govt Rains Sops On Transgenders

HT Correspondent, Hindustan Times, Kolkata | Dec 25, 2015


For a community that has been marginalized for centuries now, the rise of Mamata Banerjee in West Bengal has come as a lucky break.

The Trinamool government has been raining sops on the 30,349 members of West Bengal’s transgender community, also called Hijras, with the intention of effecting their social recognition as well as financial independence. These measures include appointing India’s first transgender college principal; setting up the country’s third Transgender Development Board; considering the appointment of community members as civic police volunteers; introducing sex reorientation surgery (SRS) in state-run hospitals with dedicated beds; and constructing separate toilets for them.

“There has been a sea change in the government’s attitude towards the transgender community ever since Mamata Banerjee came to power. She is personally sensitive towards them,” said Manabi Banerjee, the transgender principal of the Krishnanagar Women’s College in Nadia district.

Manabi is also the vice-chairperson of the Transgender Development Board, which is headed by state women, child and social welfare minister Sashi Panja. The board recognizes all transsexuals, whether biological or post-operative.

Soon after the board was instituted in June, the Bengal government decided to introduce the SRS facility at a few leading government hospitals. It also offered dedicated beds to members of the community in all state-run hospitals.

According to Panja, SRS can be a costly affair if performed at a private hospital. Moreover, it should be carried out with adequate precaution to prevent future health hazards. “Individuals opting for SRS can avail proper guidance and clinical assistance from a panel of experts at government hospitals. Dedicated beds may help them avail of proper treatment, something they are often denied,” she said.

Tamil Nadu was the first state in India to set up a transgender welfare board, and offer SRS facilities at government hospitals. Later, Kerala and Maharashtra introduced similar boards of their own, along with schemes offering scholarships and homes.

Even the Centre has begun working towards ensuring transgender welfare, proposing a law that classifies them as backward and – consequently – providing much-needed reservation with regard to education and employment in the government sector. The proposed law, which comes three months after a private member bill on transgenders was approved by the Rajya Sabha, also provides for host of social sector benefits such as pensions and scholarships.

Taking its pro-transsexual campaign forward, the West Bengal government recently reached out to the corporate world too. Panja, in an address to the eighth CII Corporate Social Responsibility Meet 2015 at Kolkata, requested corporate houses to dedicate a portion of their CSR funds to installing separate toilets for transgenders. “They deserve separate toilets, which – unfortunately – are not there. Just imagine the difficulties faced by them. They are all humans. The government alone cannot do everything. Please come forward and help us achieve our social goals,” she said.

The country’s first toilet for transsexuals was constructed in Mysore, Karnataka, on November 19, 2015.

Panja’s request to Kolkata police commissioner Surajit Kar Purakayashta, seeking the recruitment of people from the community as civic police volunteers, has earned praises from various quarters too. “A section of the community is often seen begging at important crossings. It’s good that the government trusts the same people to manage traffic as well,” said Dr Tirthankar Guha Thakurta, a member of the LGBT community.

However, not everybody is looking at this picture with rose-tinted glasses. “It’s true that the government has begun making these people dream of a better life. But, over the past six months, there have just been decisions and announcements. Steps taken towards implementing these decisions are hard to trace. I doubt if the government has the money to turn its announcements to reality,” said Ranjit Sinha, secretary of the Association of Transgender/Hijra in Bengal, and a member of the state’s transgender development board.

Saturday, December 26, 2015

Transletter

Sophia Abella Message To Narendra Modi - LGBT India And Community

Namaste Narendra Modi Sir,

I am a transgender model living in the Philippines and I always had a dream to act in Bollywood films.

I really appreciate the changes what you have made for growth of India and entire world is talking about your success. You have really done great work but when I see the kind life of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people live in India and not accepted as part of society, I really feel sad.


Is it our fault if we are born this way? Why India cannot allow same sex marriages and accept LGBT, the way US did? Why Indian transsexuals are not accepted as part of society? Why they can't get education and a proper job? Why do they have to live like a beggar?

You have done a great job in taking India towards progress and entire world appreciate your efforts. My request to you is do something transgender people in India. Give them life, get them acceptance in society. You are the man what India needed for change and I hope you will take bold moves and accept the reality and make changes in law.

I am planning to do a Bollywood film - Love Actually, which will feature a love story of transsexual woman, I am not sure if conservative society of India will allow this film to be released.


I am not sure if Indian government will allow me to fly to India and allow me to work on this film and if Indian Censor Board allow this film to be released but I am still willing to make this effort to do this film and I hope it will bring change and might help transgender community in India to fight for a better life.

I hope this message will reach to you and I will get support from you and people in India.

Sincerely, Sophia Abella

Monday, August 24, 2015

Transletter

Bizman Ajay Mafatlal, First Major Sex Change Case, Passes Away

Press Trust of India | Mumbai
August 23, 2015

Businessman Ajay Mafatlal, who was Aparna till a sex change operation, of the Yogindra Mafatlal Group, passed away after a month-long illness at a hospital here.

He was 60.

Ajay died at the Breach Candy Hospital yesterday afternoon due to cardio-respiratory failure, according to the hospital and family sources.

He was first admitted to the Cumballa Hill Hospital on July 30 with urinary tract and lung infections, but soon he developed sepsis, following which he was shifted to the Breach Candy hospital.

He was one of the most famous and earliest sex change cases in the country. In November 2003, he underwent a surgery at the age of 46.

Aparna was in November 1979 married to family friend Sudeep Parikh who was into the business of producing yarns. After living together for one-and-half years, they mutually agreed to get separated, and in 1984, got formally divorced.

Ajay's funeral was held at the Banganga cremation grounds last evening in the presence of family members and close friends. His mother Madhuri Mafatlal, whom he was very close to, was cremated at the same place two years back.

Ajay always maintained that he wanted to live like man as he never felt like a woman.

He and his mother Madhuri were embroiled in a bitter property battle with his younger brother Atulya and the latter's estranged wife Sheetal.

Though Ajay had denied that property dispute with Atulya had anything to with his sex change, rumour mills never died. Before Aparna became Ajay, Atulya was the only son to have a claim on the late Yogindra Mafatlal's trust, as all the four sisters, including Aparna, had been married off.

After the death of the patriarch Yogindra Mafatlal over a decade ago, an intense family feud started between Ajay and Atulya over the 10,000-sqft family mansion on Altamount Road here, with Atulya and Sheetal on one side and Madhuri and Ajay on the other side.

To put an end to the dispute, their mother allowed partition of the Altamount Road mansion.

However, the feud between Ajay and Atulya intensified after Madhuri, a few months before her death in July 2013, declared Ajay as here only son. Following this, Ajay too disowned Atulya as his brother.

Friday, July 3, 2015

Transletter

Exclusive: Monica Dogra On Her Project For LGBT+, Intentions, And The Controversy That Followed

Jul 02, 2015
By Kanika Katyal

Singer-actor Monica Dogra, recently let out a ‘call-to-action’ for her new project, Shiver, which aims to appeal to “legislators all over the world to decriminalise all consensual acts of sex regardless of gender identification“. By means of a video and accompanying webpage, she explained that she was seeking to crowd source funds for a project that will strike at the heart of Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, which makes homosexuality illegal in India.

Call it an ironic turn of events, if you may, that a campaign aimed at achieving solidarity, sparked off a controversy and was slammed on social media.

In an exclusive chat with Youth Ki Awaaz, she talks about her project, her intentions, the controversy that followed and more.

Kanika Katyal (KK): Tell us in detail about your new project “Shiver”. It has sparked off a controversy. Do you think it is justified?

Monica Dogra (MD): Shiver is a one of a kind music video art project, with expanding goals. It is meant to take on the double fold agenda of mainstreaming transgender representation in popular culture and collapse gender binaries that operate around us. Depending on the money we raise, we will either make just a music video, or it will expand to include an installation documentary art piece, or it will expand further to include live performances from the choreographer and dancers hired. The music video uses magic realism and mythical narrative around the divine feminine set in the desert landscapes in Rajasthan using a young boy as a protagonist.

The seeds for Shiver were first laid when I was part of a Live Art installation protesting gender violence alongside a fierce Trans activist Aher Abheena. The project was initiated by an organization called Engendered, a trans-national arts and human rights organization that uses culture to catalyze change. During this participation I saw the kind of disruptions that can be affected when traditional boundaries of art object and the commodity system within which it is circulated as currency are dissolved. Art can be significant in challenging and complicating the hierarchies that prevail in social spaces and are ingrained in culture. In simple words, I saw the effect of having a hijra person in a high fashion outfit lending dignity and elevating an art installation in a gallery situation where trans-visibility is almost nil. This further led up to a project where I recently acted in Rosie Haber’s short film “Relapse”, opposite queer rights activist Casey Legler playing a queer wife to Cole, a character who newly self defines as trans and decides to take hormones.

I assume that our campaign Shiver sparked off a controversy for various reasons. Firstly, perhaps there is an assumption that I am capitalizing on a movement, having not engaged with the issues and communities that I am attempting to help/represent. Which is not true, because I've worked with the issue of gender my entire life through my art.

In my early concerts with Electro-Rock band Shaa’ir+Func, I have cross-dressed at shows in Mumbai where I have also crowd-surfed. As a South Asian immigrant I have grappled with the notion of being the ‘other’, all my life. If you observe, my lyrics have always dealt with issues of identity, of gender being a performance, of feminist discourse. In my journey of reverse migration to India as a performer, I have continued to think about ideas of belonging and marginalization.

I have protested the objectification of women and gender violence by being part of a public art intervention by standing for hours on the lawns of the American Center in Delhi along with sculptor Alex Davis’s STOP installation as part of WAR (Women Art and Resistance), a multidisciplinary arts project. I have seen the power of public art interventions first-hand, alongside other well-known performance artists like Maya Krishna Rao and queer artist Balbir Krishan which was very empowering and created a strong dialogue for change.

My conversations with the trans-hijra community have continued over the years, and I was recently invited to speak at the National Hijra Habba organized by the HIV AIDS Alliance and Pehchaan, an organization that does grassroots campaigning with over 250 CBOs across the nation.

These are just some of my work and engagement with community and the issues.

Secondly, this issue of Rs. 50 lakh as budget for the video. There is an overall sentiment of that being an exorbitant amount of money. Anyone who works in mainstream entertainment production will testify that this is untrue. Especially given that we are talking about an international crew, with travel budgets and a high production value. Also, and more importantly, why is it okay to spend tens of crores on a Bollywood fantasy song and dance, but not okay to have a 50 lakh project for a music video on transgender visibility? And who sets this economic bar and value to how much TG representation should be worth? There has been a huge push from the TG – Hijra community for mainstreaming their visibility in media and the entertainment world. All the legislation, the academic discourse has not translated to any changes or shifts in societal attitudes for the Hijra communities in India. Their access to education, health benefits & jobs stay seriously limited. Even within the LGBT movement, there are huge class and economic divides that keep the TG/Hijra movement largely separate and invisibilised.

Because the video is cause-oriented it somehow plays into people’s perceptions that I am privileged and taking advantage of that. But that is not the case; I’m just one of the voices in this global movement for a much needed fight for equality. Yes, I was born in America. But, I have lived in India for nearly 10 years. In America, I endured a fair amount of racism for being Indian. I look Indian, I was raised culturally very Indian. If there are activists and organizations who want to start fundraising campaigns on this issue I am more than happy to support them. As an artist I am open to constructive criticism which helps me improve my work.

KK: Your project aims to act as a catalyst for the LGBTQI+ rights in India. So why not collaborate with Indian artists?

MD: How has this assumption been made that I am not collaborating with Indian artists? The entire casting for dancers, performers, stylists, technicians, light crew etc are Indian. It just so happens that my DOP and choreographer are not. But we are increasingly living in a global world where these distinctions and boxes for nationalist identities are fast dissolving. At least I am part of that tribe.

Ryan Heffington’s choreography is provocative, soul-stirring, and communicates beyond class, race, or demographic. I find him to be one of the most incredible modern choreographers alive today. Carolina Costa, our DOP, has a film at Cannes, and there is no mistake why, she is technically a supreme architect behind the camera. Rosie Haber, as a director, has the ability to make paintings frame by frame, with a languid, melancholic, dripping ache that I find to be so sensitive and exciting. I see no reason not to make quality art with people who are leaders in their field of expertise just because they are not Indian. And our allies and partners are from various communities and organizations. For example: Engendered, The Transnational Arts and Human Rights Organization, which has a history of cultural production work around gender and sexuality in both the US as well as India. Also the Godrej Culture Lab that is a fluid experimental space that cross-pollinates ideas and people to explore what it means to be modern and Indian.

KK: Critics found your language problematic. The whole idea of “fine art” was seen as elitist. But this again leads to the larger debate, according to which art that is not directly occupied at the grass-root level is seen as bourgeois and hence lacking any ‘real’ sentiments. What do you think of the politics of that? Do you think that the avant-garde nature of your project, somewhere threatens to overshadow the cause?

MD: This is the part I understand. I am an artist. I am not an activist in the ways that many people reading and dissecting this project may be. In order to become an activist I have much to learn. We lacked understanding of how careful language must be on issue based crowd funding campaigns, how delicate with context, and how extremely precise. This is no excuse; language is now being carefully selected and clarified with support from our partners and friends from the LGBT movement. Every true remark questioning the project and asking for clarification is being addressed. I don’t feel the need to completely be transparent with the nature of the project, just because some people are up in arms about the amount of money we are asking for.

Please note, none of the funds are being pocketed by me or the team, in fact, I am fronting funds. I am hoping this doesn’t detract from the only important thing in all of this, which is the issue. At the recent Hijra Habba, I sat on live panels with the Minister of Social Justice and some incredible trans activists from various states. I heard and participated in intense discussions from these very lawmakers, and legislation writers about the importance of the transgender community to be mainstreamed. Though bills have been passed, and there are court dates in place, there are no plans for implementation of these laws. The social stigma around the TG/Hijra community is still too deep and unless we translate the issue into popular culture and conversation, no law can actually become effective.

KK: How would you describe the activism in your art?

MD: I touched upon this earlier but, feminist themes have been a part of my life for as long as I can remember. I play with gender, sexual agency; discuss objectification, love, society, and truth through the lyrics of my songs. I stake claim on my own freedom of expression through my music videos, the production of my live performances, and the conceptualizing of my album artworks. I believe that self-loving and respecting one’s self is the most radical thing a human being can do, and struggle with it myself, every day. I’m definitely struggling with it right now. People, who have come to my shows and have met me post, know that I look people in the eyes, soul to soul, and that my desire to build community and build empathy is real. It always has been. I have always tried to use my lyrics as a way to create change and I learn every day. Through this project with the support from various people I want to take a step further.

You just have to step outside your door to understand that the overall culture of our country towards marginalized communities is one of intolerance. With my team and campaign backers, we want to amplify the cause via mainstream. The project features members of the trans community with equal roles, getting paid ethically through this work, collaborating as creative partners.

KK: You’ve always identified yourself as a queer ideal. What does the project hold for you on a personal level?

MD: I see my sexuality as fluid. I sit with myself, and wonder how many of my choices are rooted in truth, and how many are perhaps subconsciously driven by a desire to assimilate, be loved, and fit in. I believe that a society that is inclusive and celebratory of difference is one that I would like my children to live in. Wikipedia says that “Queer is an umbrella term for sexual and gender minorities who are not heterosexual or cisgender.” I don’t relate to the gender experience of many of my hetero sisters. I don’t relate to the confines of sexual orientation labels, therefore I identify as queer.

KK: Sisterhood is an important theme of Shiver. How important is its relevance in the current scenario of feminist discourses in India and worldwide?

MD: I can only speak on what I know. “Sisterhood”, is taken from a lyric of the song… which says,
“The sisterhood of the alone-ones, the ones who know what it means to create the loneliness that you dream to be free of, because it offers you control.”

When I write, I often just open the tap and let it all pour out. I remember what I was feeling at the time of writing this. Often, we find women targeting women in cruel and misogynistic ways worse than even a man could/would. There is a legacy, world-wide, of the admonishment of the feminine. Men are encouraged to ignore their inner feminine. There are many layers to this. Marginalized groups, in order to survive, become insular, protective, and are slow to integrate, fearing misunderstanding, fearing being hurt. That is why, the independent scene in India is very slow to acknowledge something positive in Bollywood.

Through Shiver we’d like to highlight the experience of the feminine, not the external forms. I still hold this to be self-evident, that we are all human, we all want love, we all want a place in society, we all want dignity, we all want self-respect, and all of these things are our birth rights. How this plays out in feminist discourse world-wide, I simply do not know. I’m an artist. I go about making art. I am much simpler than many think.



Friday, May 29, 2015

Transletter

Op-ed: I'm A Trans Man Who Doesn't 'Pass' — And You Shouldn't Either
To paraphrase Janet Mock: Trans people aren't 'passing' as men or women. We're being.

BY Aiden James Kosciesza
May 20 2015 6:00 AM ET

Out of all the words in the transgender lexicon, “passing” is the one I ate most. And that’s no small feat.

In our rapidly evolving digital world, language is changing faster than ever. Words that seemed to be standard terminology as little as four years ago are now out of fashion, or even taboo. When I began my gender transition in 2011, for example, I called myself a “transsexual,” a word I no longer use because of its implied connection between gender identity and sexuality. Yet as words like “tranny” slink out of circulation, “passing” remains frustratingly well-used, even among the trans* community.

The term “passing,” when applied to transgender people, means being perceived as cisgender while presenting as one’s authentic gender identity. There’s a lot of power in that. When people meet me and assume that I am a cisgender man, I am afforded the privilege of choosing whether I disclose my transgender identity, and when. Many trans* folks pursue this power through clothing choices, hormones, surgery, voice training, or even etiquette lessons, and I’m all for that.

For many of us, the goal of transition is equally balanced between feeling comfortable in our own skin and showing the world who we really are. The problem is that when trans* people use the word “passing” for what we’ve achieved, it diminishes everything that we’re fighting for.

To “pass” for something immediately connotes deception and untruth. Think of plagiarists passing off someone else’s work as their own, a look-alike cousin who could easily pass for his relative, or the mocking lines of Shakespeare’s Portia in Merchant of Venice: “God made him, and therefore let him pass for a man.”

To look at trans* people expressing their authentic selves and say that they “pass” for men or women is to diminish their identity by implying that it’s an act. Telling a trans* woman that she “passes” is like saying “You’re not a real woman, but good job faking it.”

If that sounds like a slap in the face, well — it is. Yet both transgender people and their allies continue to use this term, despite prominent advocates like Janet Mock speaking out against it. Even articles that call out the term for being controversial and negative will turn around and use it throughout. The problem is that despite the terrible word we use for it, the concept of “passing” is very real, and creates a hierarchy of privilege that can’t be ignored.

We have to talk about the divide between trans* people who have the privilege of choosing disclosure and those who don’t. It’s a divide as stark as any racial barrier, and erasing the conversation about that difference would be a step backward. But we need to change the words that we use, because the term “passing” perpetuates harmful stereotypes that cast trans* people as imposters.

The idea that transgender people are inherently deceptive is not only insulting, it’s dangerous. Perhaps the most famous example of this danger is the case of Gwen Araujo, who was killed after men who had consensual sexual relations with her discovered that she had “male” genitalia. The murderers mounted the “trans panic” defense in court, claiming that this “crime of passion ... did not merit a charge of first degree murder.” And it worked. The men were convicted only of second-degree murder. Although Araujo’s case may be the most famous, it’s far from the only instance of trans* women being attacked by cisgender men who claim they were deceived.

This leaves trans* people stuck in the middle of an impossible divide: If we are easily, visibly identifiable as transgender, we may be insulted, ridiculed, denied jobs or housing, harassed, attacked, or killed. But if we are not so easily picked out of the crowd, we risk an even more vitriolic reaction if we are “discovered” — now we’re not only trans*, we’re liars too.

At the heart of this problem is the word “passing” itself. Language has power. When people tell us — or worse, when we tell ourselves — that we’re only “passing” as men or women, that our identities are a sham or a mask meant to trick the rest of the world, the narrative of deception takes hold. “Trans panic” murders are the most horrifying consequence of this narrative, but it also seeps into everyday life in subtle ways.

This narrative of deception remains a part of public policy, even though transgender people are gaining acceptance and visibility like never before. I came face-to-face with this stereotype the last time I donated blood through the American Red Cross. The volunteers themselves were very kind and helpful, but when I explained that I am transgender, the Red Cross computer system forced the volunteers to go through the entire blood donation questionnaire with me out loud, in person. Normally these questions would be completed by the donor alone, through the computer, which both increases privacy and allows the volunteers to take donations more efficiently.

My volunteer was flummoxed. “I’ve never seen this before,” she told me apologetically. “I don’t know why it’s making you answer all of this out loud!”

I knew why. “Because trans* people are inherently deceptive,” I said with heavy irony. It was humiliating to be treated that way — as if my gender identity, which I had just voluntarily disclosed, meant that I couldn’t be trusted to answer the questions honestly.

The volunteer missed my ironic tone. She turned to me with a concerned, albeit hesitant look. “Oh ... Is that true?”

If I’d answered yes, I’m sure she would have believed me.

This is the stigma that we’re fighting. Transgender people and our allies must not buy into the idea that we are liars, that we’re putting one over on the world, that we can’t be trusted. To paraphrase Janet Mock, we’re not “passing.” We’re being.

Trans* people need a new word to replace “passing.” I prefer "being recognized."

When I’m recognized as male, it means that the people around me can see who I truly am — thanks in part to the hormones, clothing, name, and pronouns I've chosen. Being recognized still acknowledges that work on my part and the changes I've made to align my gender presentation with my internal gender identity, but it also leaves the power to define that identity in my own hands. I have always been male, even before I knew it myself. When others correctly recognize my gender, they’re not being misled. They are respecting the person I am and the way I choose to show myself to the world.

Transgender people, please: Stop “passing.” Leave the outdated, insulting, and dangerous terminology behind, and let the world recognize your authentic, courageous lives.

AIDEN JAMES KOSCIESZA is a public speaker who visits universities, hospitals, and organizations to talk about transgender identities. Follow him on social media (@transaidenjames, facebook.com/trans.aiden.james) or on the Web at www.aiden-james.com. He lives in Media, Pa., where he teaches English and awaits his life-changing book deal.

*Editor's Note: The asterisk after the word "trans" indicates the writer's usage as an umbrella term that aims to reflect the vast diversity of identities and experiences of individuals who identify as transgender, transsexual, intersex, nonbinary, and otherwise gender-nonconforming.

Thursday, April 30, 2015

Transletter

Bruce Jenner’s Transgender ‘Coming Out': He’s Not Alone, But Is It In The Genes?

By A. J. Smuskiewicz | April 23, 2015 | Genetic Literacy Project

“Transgender.” Just a few years ago, one hardly ever heard or saw that word in the news media. Now, hardly a week goes by without encountering at least one mainstream news story on this peculiar subject.

In early 2015, stories about the gender transition of Bruce Jenner, the 65-year-old former Olympian, were all over the news. Most of these stories focused on salacious rumors about Jenner’s transition, paparazzi photographs showing his painted fingernails or signs of breast growth beneath his shirt, or concerns within the LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender) community about the “spectacle” of it all.

It did indeed seem like an out-of-control media spectacle in the days leading up to Jenner’s highly anticipated public “coming out” TV extravaganza, marked by appearances on Good Morning America and capped by a two-hour interview with Diane Sawyer on ABC’s 20/20 on April 24, 2015.


Jenner revealed personal info about “the journey, the decisions, the future”; the Kardashian clan was reported to be worried about how Jenner’s comments might affect the reality-TV family’s reputation; and the first photo secretly obtained of Jenner wearing a dress was pasted across the Internet.

One thing I did not see in any of these breathless stories about Jenner was a serious, scientific discussion about the possible causes of transgenderism, including genetic influences.

As a 55-year-old individual who has struggled with my gender identity for more than 40 years—still without completely resolving the struggle or conflict—I have long been curious about the causes of transgenderism. My curiosity stands in contrast to most of my transgender friends—many of whom have fully transitioned (unlike myself). They generally show no interest in what caused them to be the way they are, and they tell me that I should stop worrying about causes and simply accept it and be happy about it. But I can’t do that.


Perhaps it is my background in science that makes me need to ask, “Why do I have these feminine feelings? Why do I like to wear women’s clothes? Why do I sometimes live as a woman, and why do I sometimes want to become fully female?”

Media Incuriosity or Fear?

With the increasing media attention being given to the T in LGBT, one would think such answers would be fairly easy to find these days. But that would be an incorrect assumption. Like my transgender friends, almost all media reports on this matter simply acknowledge how wonderful it is for transgender people to express themselves, and how wrong it is for transgender people to be discriminated against. I agree with those sentiments. But where is the scientific curiosity about the gender identity issue?

As with homosexuality, media reports about transgenderism almost never ask “Why?” Why are some people homosexual or transgendered? Might it be related in some way to certain experiences while growing up? Is it something in their genes? If so, what exactly? It is considered politically incorrect—a sign of intolerance and bigotry—to ask such questions. That’s what I have been told by a number of people who work in both journalism and science. And whenever I have raised such questions in LGBT online discussion boards, I have been shot down with angry comments, such as “There is no such research!” “Stop asking those stupid questions!” “Who cares anyway?” “What are you, a troll bigot?”

Geez! That kind of ignorant, willingly blind attitude drives me crazy! (Also driving me crazy is the way the media lumps together all forms of transgenderism as a single, monolithic issue. News flash: “Transgender” can mean a wide variety of things. For example, a transvestite and a transsexual are both transgender, but they are very different. One enjoys dressing like a woman but considers himself male; the other actually wants to be a woman and considers himself female. And there are some people, like me, who are caught somewhere between the two—not exactly sure which one best applies to us.)

Personally, I tend to agree with Lady Gaga that LGBT people were “born this way.” I suspect that certain gene mutations or other congenital factors (such as certain unusual conditions in the womb) result in tendencies toward various types of transgenderism or homosexuality. Nevertheless, I still want to know what the latest science says about this matter. But reports of such science are rarely encountered in the mass media, such as television or newspapers.

Every now and then, however, one does hear or see stories about scientific findings regarding LGBT issues. The best chance of finding these stories is through the use of carefully targeted Internet searches.

Gay And Transgender Genes?

In 2014, several media outlets carried reports of an interesting study of 409 pairs of homosexual brothers. (This study was formally published in the May 2015 issue of Psychological Medicine.) The researchers found evidence that sexual orientation in men is influenced by certain single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) on chromosome 8 and the X chromosome. This study was described by New Scientist in November 2014 as “the strongest evidence yet that gay people are born gay.”

But even New Scientist, though it properly covered the research findings, felt the need to editorialize: “Ultimately, what causes homosexuality doesn’t matter as much as the fact that homosexual people exist, and have always existed, in every society on earth. In the words of the activists: some people are gay. Get over it.

Is it necessary to add such aggressive, activist, off-putting commentary to a science story? I think not. I also think it is wrong for an allegedly scientific publication to proclaim that a scientific finding on any subject “doesn’t matter.”

Regarding my personal interest in LGBT matters, Rolling Stone ran a brief, although welcomed, article in July 2014 titled “The Science of Transgender: Understanding The Causes of Being Transgender.” Writer Sabrina Rubin Erdely noted:

…a growing body of research is pointing to biological origins. The 2008 discovery by Australian researchers of a genetic variation in transgender women—their receptor gene for the sex hormone testosterone was longer, making it less efficient at communicating signals—set off speculation that insufficient uptake of male hormones in utero contributed to a “more feminised brain.” And the brains of trans people do look different. Recent Spanish imaging studies have shown that the white matter of untreated trans men look much like those of biological males, and that the patterns of trans women’s white matter fell about halfway between those of biological male and female control groups.

Erdely also noted that the role of genetics in shaping transgender identity remains very much unknown, noting, “a recent survey of identical twins found that only in 20 percent of cases did both twins turn out transgender, despite having identical DNA.”

Such media reports are refreshing, because they at least indicate to the public that science is trying to figure out a subject that is usually discussed in only political or social terms. Even if the science is currently too complex for even scientists to understand—with unknown interactions of genetic and environmental influences—it is important that writers in the media honestly convey that information to the public. Why keep it a secret? Any kind of information based on scientific evidence is always good to share.

LGBT Objections

Unfortunately, some people in the LGBT community object to studies that investigate the genetic roots of gender or sexual identity. Perhaps that is why these kinds of studies get so little coverage in the mainstream media—and maybe also why there are so few such studies to begin with. Look at some of the seemingly fearful, who-cares-about-science comments in reaction to a November 2014 Huffington Post story about the Psychological Medicine gay brothers study:

1. “On the question of whether being gay is a choice or not, does it matter? Do people really need to validate their actions and lives in the eyes of others?”

2. “Born this way – now leave em alone.”

3. “So, are there genes that cause heterosexuality? I find this entire inquiry strange: Why not look for genes that affect sexuality, instead of homosexuality? It’s like white people trying to explain black people by looking for a gene that made them different/black. (implying that one would be normal and everything else is deviation from the norm.)”

4. “But…so what? Why does it matter why a person is gay or not? What possible use could this info have other than something that I shudder to contemplate?”

Such public comments are disheartening. Scientific knowledge should always matter—to everyone. And it should never be feared—for any reason. To quote renowned psychologist and author Steven Pinker in The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature quoting Chekhov, “Man will become better when you show him what he is like.”

We need much more scientific research into the causes—genetic and otherwise—of homosexual and transgender behaviors, as well as all other forms of human behavior and sexuality. Why? Because knowledge about human behavior and sexuality is essential to understanding what being human is all about. And investigating what it means to be human is one of the noblest quests of science. Then, after the science, we need honest media reports about this research—free from political agendas, advocacy, or fear mongering.

In a story about the Psychological Medicine gay brothers study in February 2014, The Guardian included insightful comments by Qazi Rahman, a psychologist at King’s College London:

“This is not controversial or surprising and is nothing people should worry about. All human psychological traits are heritable, that is, they have a genetic component,” he said. “Genetic factors explain 30 to 40% of the variation between people’s sexual orientation. However, we don’t know where these genetic factors are located in the genome. So we need to do ‘gene finding’ studies, like this one by Sanders, Bailey and others, to have a better idea where potential genes for sexual orientation may lie.”

Rahman rejected the idea that genetics research could be used to discriminate against people on the basis of their sexual orientation. “I don’t see how genetics would contribute more to the persecution, discrimination and stigmatisation of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people any more than social, cultural or learning explanations. Historically, the persecution and awful treatment of LGBT groups has been because politicians, religious leaders and societies have viewed sexual orientation as ‘choice’ or due to poor upbringing.”

I would go a bit further, by offering my own version of FDR’s famous proclamation: “…let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear of science itself.”

A. J. Smuskiewicz is a freelance writer specializing in science and medicine, including issues of human sexuality and gender. He can be contacted at: ajsmuskie@gmail.com.

Sunday, February 22, 2015

Transletter

Dutee Chand – The Athlete And The Gender Controversy

11 Feb 2015
By Bhavya (Athletics, Editorials, INDIA)

Dutee Chand announced her arrival back on the track with a bang. In the Orissa State Championships, she bagged a gold medal in the 100 meters event and is now eagerly waiting to perform in the National Games in Kerala. But for a long time, Dutee Chand was barred from participating for no fault of hers,  Sports Rediscovered takes a look at her story…

The current National champion in the women’s 100 meters event. Talented, hardworking and dedicated.
Missed the ticket to the Commonwealth Games though.
Why?

Apparently, her achievements were not good enough.
Wondering what constitutes ‘good enough’?

The right kind of hormones !


This is the story of Dutee Chand – first Indian to reach the final of a world youth event. She is also the National Champion in the under-18 100m category. Yet she was denied entry into the 2014 Commonwealth and Asian Games because of a condition known as ‘hyperandrogenism’ (excess of androgens, which in Dutee’s case meant excessive testosterone).

Sufferers Before Dutee Chand:
This is not an isolated incident. Caster Semenya, Sarah Gronert, Stella Walsh, Pinki Pramanik and many more have had to face the ire of the world after failing what were known earlier as gender tests. Most went with the tide. The gender scrutiny being too much to handle, they hung up their shoes. Dutee, however, chose to take the road less travelled – and challenged the authorities.

Dutee was given the option to return to the track on the condition that she either takes hormone suppressing drugs or gets a surgery done to limit the testosterone production. Dutee turned down the offer. Why should she not?  Are we telling a promising athlete that she ‘needs’ to genetically alter her body to prove her worth? Are we going to punish her for something as natural as sweat and blood?


We need to understand how ‘Gender’ and ‘Sex’ are two different things. The difference is slight and easy to miss, but the ambiguity concerning it has to be brought into light. ‘Sex’, is a biological idea, while ‘Gender’ is a social and cultural construct.
Sadly, the ideas of “frailty” and “elegance” have now become central to the idea of being a woman. A woman who does not fit into these categories is tagged “unfeminine”. Are these ‘gender tests’ not preposterous? Are we banning an athlete from participating in the sport of her choice because she is not “womanly enough”? Should not an athlete be treated simply on the basis of her merit?

Help From The Sports Authority Of India
Thankfully for Dutee Chand, the Sports Authority of India (SAI) extended its support. Jiji Thompson, the man at the helm at that time, sent out a statement clearing all questions regarding the nature of the test and helped Dutee plead her case at the Court of Arbitration for Sports (CAS).

On the 18th of December, the Court of Arbitration for Sports (CAS) allowed the sprinter to participate in national and state level events till a final verdict was reached on her appeal against International Amateur Athletics Association’s (IAAF) hyperandrogenism policy.

“Sport celebrates human diversity, regardless of inherent natural characteristics. Such a policy is contrary to the spirit of sports. Only women athletes fall under these regulations and there is enough evidence that athletes from countries like India are targeted and tested under this policy. So this policy of discrimination against women needs to be stopped immediately.” SAI Director General Jiji Thomson said. Food for thought indeed. Why is it that “only female athletes” fall under such an inspection? Firstly, this professes the idea that the male body is the norm and that to have “so-called-manly-features” is an advantage in sports. So a person’s sexuality has to be questioned if they exhibit “abnormal” characteristics. Going by that logic, strength, stamina and speed can be attributed only to men and if a woman displays any of these, she’s “manly”.

Let us take a moment to consider Michael Phelps here. The body proportions that help him cut through water with such elegance could be because of “Marfan Syndrome”. If physical build is not a point of debate, then why should hormones be?

The sooner the ambiguous views on Gender and Sex are cleared, the better it is for these athletes toiling hard, day in and day out, to achieve their dreams. To bar them from taking part in competitions because of this ambiguity is a merciless practice. Here’s hoping the courage that Dutee Chand has shown will help in bringing a change in the world of athletics.

A natural sprinter like Dutee, finds herself in the middle of a long marathon, to prove that she belongs. She is running against years of prejudice. This is one race where Dutee is a winner , irrespective of the verdict by CAS , for she has not only taken the road less traveled but is striving for greater inclusivity in all sports.