Monday, October 10, 2016

Transletter

States, UTs Have To Certify Person As Transgender: Delhi HC
By PTI | Tue, 27 Sep 2016

New Delhi: Certifying a person as a transgender is the responsibility of the state governments and Union territories, the Centre has told Delhi High Court. The submission was made by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment in an affidavit placed before Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva who is hearing pleas of two Delhi-based transgenders seeking change of their names and gender from male to female in the government records.

The ministry has said that a committee set up by it in October 2013 to make an in-depth study of problems faced by the transgender community has recommended that a certificate that a person is a transgender should be issued by the respective states or Union territories. With the above submission, the ministry, represented by central government standing counsel Monika Arora, has sought dismissal of the pleas of the two transgenders.

The ministry had earlier told the court that a bill has been introduced in Parliament on August 2 which takes care of all the prayers raised by the two in their plea. The petitioners have alleged discrimination by the authorities and sought "disciplinary enquiry" against them.

In support of their claims, they have referred to a Supreme Court order holding that a person's self-defined sexual orientation and gender identity is integral to their personality and a person cannot be forced to undergo medical procedures, including SRS or hormonal therapy, as a requirement for legal recognition of their gender identity.

The two have claimed that they were MtF (male to female) transsexuals who, due to duality between their appearance, voice, mannerism, dressing style and their male IDs, faced discrimination in the society. The petitioners have contended that the department officials had refused to consider their applications for change of name without a certificate stating that they had undergone Sexual Reassignment Surgery (SRS). They have sought quashing of any guideline of the publications department which mandates an SRS before changing the gender, as well as directions to the Centre "to constitute a board or committee for certifying the petitioner as a MtF transgender". They have also contended that "the action of respondents in refusing to allow the name change infringes the petitioner's fundamental right to live with dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution".

Friday, August 19, 2016

Transletter

Delhi HC Asks Government To Explain The Problem In Transgenders Changing Their Names

Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva raised the query while hearing pleas of two transgenders seeking change of their names and gender from male to female in government records.

By: PTI | New Delhi | August 16, 2016

The Delhi High Court has fixed the matter for hearing on October 4.
The Delhi High Court on Tuesday asked the government to explain what problem it has in changing the names of two transgenders from male to female in the official records.

Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva raised the query while hearing the pleas of two city-based transgenders seeking change of their names and gender from male to female in the government records.

“Have you not published any name change in your Gazette (public journal)? Change of gender is something different. What is the problem in a name change,” the court asked the counsel for Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and the Controller of Publications, which publishes the Gazette.

Government lawyers said they will seek instructions regarding the queries raised by the court.

Central government standing counsel Monika Arora said a bill has been introduced in the Parliament on August 2, which takes care of all the prayers raised by the two in their plea.

The court has fixed the matter for hearing on October 4.

The petitioners have alleged discrimination by the authorities and sought “disciplinary enquiry” against them.

In support of their claims, they referred to a Supreme Court order holding that a person’s self-defined sexual orientation and gender identity is integral to their personality and a person cannot be forced to undergo medical procedures, including SRS or hormonal therapy, as a requirement for legal recognition of their gender identity.

The two have claimed that they were MtF (male to female) transsexuals who, due to duality between their appearance, voice, mannerism, dressing style and their male IDs, faced discrimination in the society.

The petitioners have contended that the department officials had refused to consider their applications for change of name without a certificate stating that they had undergone Sexual Reassignment Surgery (SRS).

They have sought quashing of any guideline of the publications department which mandates an SRS before changing the gender, as well as directions to the Centre “to constitute a board or committee for certifying the petitioner as a MtF transgender”.

They have also contended that “the action of respondents in refusing to allow the name change infringes the petitioner’s fundamental right to live with dignity under Article 21 of the Constitution”.

Source: http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-news-india/delhi-hc-asks-government-to-explain-the-problem-in-transgenders-changing-their-names-2978912/

Friday, May 20, 2016

Transletter

Acceptance By Society Is The Greatest Recognition For Me
By Arya UR | May 20, 2016

It is not easy being a transgender in India, let alone in Kerala, where they are ridiculed to such an extent that they keep away from all kinds of public spaces. But transgender and dancer Jazz D' Souza decided to take the chance when she auditioned for a TV reality show in a popular Malayalam channel. Not only did Jazz get selected, she received applause for her performances in the show, while becoming the first third gender contestant to participate in a TV show, probably the first in the history of Indian television. It is more than a personal victory but what is important is that she felt loved and accepted, says a beaming Jazz, as she opens up to Kochi Times about her bitter past, journey to the dance floor and dreams in life.

I Had A Traumatic Childhood

I don't want to reveal my original name or other details but I was born and brought up in Pandalam, Pathanamthitta. I was outwardly a boy but my feminine mannerisms made me a butt of jokes among children in school. So like in the case of any other member of my community, my childhood and teenage were filled with horror. My family too couldn't accept my wish to live my life as a woman. There were times when I really wanted to end my life because of the continual abuses I had suffered. But I had strong hope that I would succeed one day.

Being a member of the third gender, I was a loner in society. Public toilets were always a haunting experience. I have had to suffer physical abuses when I used the men's rooms. Women were more understanding and they have always allowed me to use their washrooms.

The Turning Point

One day, seven years ago, I ran away from home, unable to bear the torture. I reached Mumbai in pursuit of a livelihood.There is a space in Mumbai for transgenders like me and I started working as a bar dancer there. After saving enough money, I decided to undergo a sexual reassignment surgery. Thus I became a female two years ago, and got christened as Jazz D'Souza.

After my transition into a woman, I was quite determined to succeed in life. I was always fond of modelling and wanted a glamorous profession, which is why I opted to be a dancer. One day I came across a notification online about the auditions for a dance reality show on a Malayalam channel. I am a self-taught dancer but being a transgender, I was not sure if I would get selected. But the producers of the show were impressed by my performance and I was in! At first, I was shy but the other contestants, judges and the hosts gave me a warm welcome and that boosted my confidence.

I Felt Loved And Appreciated As A Contestant

It takes several rounds for a contestant to become popular in the reality show, but I received lots of applause and love from the audience at my very first performance itself. It was the greatest recognition for a transgender like me. Being a member of the most ignored community in the country, the acceptance instilled hope in me. Just when I thought things couldn't get any better, my favorite actress Shobana, who was one of the judges, praised my dance performance and asked me if I would like to enter the film industry. I was also fortunate enough to share the stage with her for a few dance steps and it was a dream come true for me.

I Now Have An Identity

The show gave me an identity and meaning in life. Now, wherever I go, people recognize me as a celebrity and wish me luck. The comments and support I receive from well-wishers around the world too make me feel blessed. I feel I can now walk down the streets as a member of the third gender with my head held high. I can't describe the feeling when young girls and boys approach me calling chechi and take selfies with me. It doesn't matter if I get eliminated from the show, because I got a perfect platform to showcase my talents and create a space for myself in society.

My Parents Are Yet To Accept Me

The best moment was when the team dedicated a video album to me "The story of a transgender's life" in its 12th episode. The video was based on the incidents in my life. It went viral and even Bollywood actor Varun Dhawan shared it. It made my parents contact me after a long time. But they were still not fully happy with me and told me to live with dignity. They had seen my performances, and even though they did not invite me back home, my mother said I performed well on stage, which gave me some comfort.

I Wish To Be An Actress, Social Worker And Mother

During childhood my dream was to become an air hostess. There are countries which have transgenders as cabin crew and I wish our government too would allow it. Now I want to become an actress. I know I can't be a heroine, but I want to essay powerful roles in films. I also want to make use of my fame as a voice for my community and serve as a social worker. I want to be in the forefront to help people of my community live a dignified life.

I also wish to get married to a man who will respect me. After becoming Jazz, I received several good proposals but when I reveal my identity to them, they withdraw. That saddens me. I hope to adopt a child as well and have a family, like any normal human being.

Friday, April 15, 2016

Transletter

High Court Seeks Government’s Reply On Transgender’s Plea For Name Change

Advocate Harsh Ahuja, appearing for the central government, told the court the issues raised by the petitioner might be covered in the The Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2015 which is pending in the Parliament.

By Press Trust of India | April 14, 2016



New Delhi: A transgender’s plea for change of name and gender from male to female in the official records has led the Delhi High Court to seek the Centre’s response. Justice Manmohan issued notice to the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment and the Controller of Publications seeking their replies on the petition of the city-based transgender who has alleged discrimination by the authorities on ground of her sexual identity and has sought “disciplinary inquiry” against them.

The court also directed its registry to redact the trans -sexual petitioner’s name from the cause title of the case and refer to her as ‘A’. It listed the matter for further hearing on August 16. The petition claims that “that petitioner is a MtF (male to female) trans-sexual who due to duality between petitioner’s appearance, voice, mannerism, dressing style and her male ID, faces discrimination in the society”. The petitioner through her lawyer told the court that the department officials have refused to consider her application for change of name without a certificate stating that she had undergone Sexual Reassignment Surgery (SRS).

Advocate Harsh Ahuja, appearing for the central government, told the court the issues raised by the petitioner might be covered in the The Rights of Transgender Persons Bill, 2015 which is pending in the Parliament. The plea said the petitioner was diagnosed with gender identity disorder in 2005 and has since been on hormone replacement therapy. It also claims that she has been living as a woman from the time she turned 19 years old. The petitioner has sought directions to the department of publications “to allow and publish in the gazette, name change of petitioner without requirement of any SRS, if needed, subject to certification of board/committee constituted for the purpose”.

Source: http://www.india.com/news/india/high-court-seeks-governments-reply-on-transgenders-plea-for-name-change-1107807/

Wednesday, February 24, 2016

Transletter

IOC's Gender Stance ‘Insensitive And Harmful’ To Athletes

Indian sprinter Dutee Chand back in limbo as IOC recommends return of hyperandrogenism rules.

By: Kerry Gillespie Sports reporter, Feb 23 2016

GRAHAM CROUCH / THE NEW YORK TIMES

Dutee Chand wants to run with the body she was born with. The young sprinter from India fought for that right all the way to the international Court of Arbitration for Sport.

She thought she had won last July when the court suspended the athletics governing body’s gender test and declared her eligible to compete.

Now, she’s not so sure.

The International Olympic Committee has released recommendations that, once again, raise questions about whether Chand and women like her, whose bodies naturally produce high levels of testosterone, will be allowed to compete at the Rio Olympics this summer.

Chand’s team of advocates, which includes Canadian and American experts, are now taking on the IOC and what they see as an “insensitive and harmful attack on women with hyperandrogenism.”

“We call on the IOC to commit to publicly respect the (court’s) decision and declare that it will not introduce hyperandrogenism regulations for the upcoming Rio Olympic Games,” states the letter sent to IOC president Thomas Bach on Monday.

It was signed by Bruce Kidd, a Toronto sport policy advisor, Katrina Karkazis, a Stanford University bioethicist and Payoshni Mitra, the university researcher who first approached Chand about fighting her case, and the rule itself, in court.

A woman who injects testosterone, or a man for that matter, will generally get an athletic benefit from it. That’s why it’s a banned performance-enhancing drug.

But, as Chand’s pro-bono lawyer, James Bunting, a sports law expert at Toronto’s Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg, was able to show, the science is far less clear in the case of hyperandrogenism.

The court stated that it was not satisfied that the degree of advantage is any greater than other variables that determine sporting excellence, ranging from good genes to proper nutrition, coaching and training.

The court determined that the policy of the international governing body for athletics, the IAAF, which set a line in the sand for testosterone — above 10 nano moles per liter and women were considered male and barred from competition until they had surgery or hormone therapy to reduce their levels — was discriminatory and lacked scientific evidence.

It gave them two years to provide scientific proof for the rule and set it aside for the time being.

The IOC’s hyperandrogenism recommendations, released publicly in late January as part of an update to its guidelines for transgendered athletes, didn’t address the scientific or ethical arguments. But it urged the IAAF and other sport organizations to return to the court “with arguments and evidence to support the reinstatement of its hyperandrogenism rules.”

Could that happen before Rio? And, if not, will the IOC decide to implement rules of its own ahead of the 2016 Games?

No one knows and that leaves Chand back in limbo.

“Last summer when the sports court declared me eligible to compete and suspended the IAAF regulations, I felt like a weight had been lifted from my shoulders. I could finally go back to focusing on my training with Olympic qualification in mind,” the 20-year-old said in a statement.

“But now the stress and anxiety has returned.”

The IOC and IAAF could not be reached in time for deadline.

For Chand, this saga began in 2014 when she was suddenly pulled from the team heading to the Glasgow Commonwealth Games after being singled out for gender testing in India because her body appeared “masculine.”

The IOC’s statement “raises the possibility of the exact same thing happening again,” Karkazis said.

Beyond the uncertainty for athletes like Chand, who do not want to undergo unnecessary treatments to alter the body they were born with, the IOC’s other recommendation is just as disappointing, she said.

“To avoid discrimination, if not eligible for female competition the athlete should be eligible to compete in male competition,” it states.

“It’s completely untrue,” Karkazis said.

“Not only would these women not qualify in the men’s categories because they’re not pulling in men’s times but their identity and legal papers don’t say anything of the sort. This is horrible language that women can just go compete as men — it’s so degrading.”

Last weekend, Chand won a bronze medal in the 60-metre sprint at the Asian Indoor Athletics Championships and, in the heats; she set an Indian national record with her time of 7.28 seconds. That ranks as the 51st fastest time in the world for women this year and it’s nowhere in the men’s field.

Chand’s supporters believe that the attempts of sport bodies to determine who is a man and who is a woman based on something as narrow as testosterone levels, with tests triggered by how “masculine” women look, is little better than the naked parades some athletes were forced to endure in the 1960s.

"An investigation can be triggered because of how someone looks," Karkazis said. " This affects all women."

Source: http://www.thestar.com/sports/amateur/2016/02/23/iocs-stand-on-masculine-women-insensitive-and-harmful.html

Wednesday, February 17, 2016

Transletter

Bold And Beautiful
Inside Auditions For India’s First Transgender Modeling Agency

BY Shelly Walia | February 15, 2016 | Quartz India

For more than a decade, Rudrani Chettri Chauhan has been fighting for the rights of her community—India’s transgenders.

Through Mitr Trust, a charity she founded in Delhi in 2005 to empower India’s sexual minorities, the 37-year-old transgender woman activist has worked to provide them education, healthcare, and the means to end violence and discrimination.

Now, she is also investing her time and energy in exploring a “different side of transgender life” that is often overlooked by the media and sneered at by popular culture—beauty.

“Half their time, especially for transgender women, is spent on trying to look beautiful,” Chauhan told Quartz.

Chauhan, who studied English literature and is an independent development consultant, is trying to set up India’s first modeling agency for the transgender community. Last week, she held an audition and photo shoot for models at Khirki Extension, a south Delhi neighborhood. The turnout wasn’t particularly high—only some 15 aspiring transgender women, or hijras, showed up.

“They don’t have the confidence yet,” she said. “We need to raise funds to groom them, create their portfolios, and so on.” For this, Chauhan has teamed up with Rishi Raj, a fashion stylist and photographer.

So far, her two fundraising pages—GoFundMe and BitGiving—have helped her get started. “We have only got Rs2100 on BitGiving, an Indian crowd sourcing platform. But, on the UK one, GoFundMe, we have already raised 1400 pounds.”

Quartz brings you a collection of photographs by Reuters from the first round of auditions on Feb, 07.

An aspiring model takes a selfie before auditioning for a transgender modelling agency set to open in New Delhi.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

A participant checks her makeup before her audition.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)
A candidate at the audition.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)
An aspirant at the audition.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)
A photo shoot during the auditions.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)
A participant awaits her turn.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

Preparing for the audition.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

Answering judges’ questions during the auditions.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

A candidate waits to enroll herself.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

An aspiring model walks in front of judges during auditions.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

A participant gets her waist measured before auditions.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)

A candidate putting on make up before auditioning.(Reuters/Adnan Abidi)
Source: http://qz.com/616930/inside-auditions-for-indias-first-transgender-modelling-agency/

Friday, January 22, 2016

Transletter

Fire Helped Me Look At LGBT Issues In Depth: Nandita Das

By Nagwa Kureshi, Hindustan Times, Mumbai | Jan 21, 2016


Nandita Das will speak about what the heterosexual community can do to make a difference to the LGBTQ cause. (Photo: Vidhi Thakur)
Compared to the west, where acceptance of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender (LGBT) community is gradually gaining hold, the Indian LGBT community has an arduous journey ahead. For every Pride March or film festival that celebrates their freedom of expression, we have instances of discrimination, rejection from society or laws that criminalize their identity.

Back in 1998, the Nandita Das-starrer Fire was one of the first mainstream Indian films to highlight homosexual relations and portray lesbian relationships in a sensitive manner. But the nationwide unrest that followed the release highlighted the prejudice towards the community. Subsequently, the actor also participated in events like Hijra Habba in Bangalore (an event that celebrates the transgender community) and has often spoken on the subject.

This weekend, the actor-director will be part of a panel discussion, Pride and Prejudice, which explores the contribution of straight allies (heterosexual men and women) in the movement for equal rights. “For any society to grow, we have to take up each other’s causes and speak up for each other. It shouldn’t be that only women fight for women and those with disability fight for the disabled. For me, this is an issue of discrimination and oppression and I feel compelled to speak,” she says.

Looking back, Das admits that Fire had a tangible impact. “It provided a trigger, a reason to talk about these issues in the public domain. Fire helped me look at the issue with greater depth and sensitivity. It was a landmark film, one that I’m glad happened”.

Nandita Das-starrer Fire was one of the first mainstream Indian films to highlight homosexual relations and portray lesbian relationships in a sensitive manner.
Since then, there have been some films that have revolved around the community, but LGBT themes still don’t find widespread representation in Indian cinema. “The way an LGBT person is represented in a film, has to be more thoughtful, more true to reality, as opposed to stereotyping, or worse not having their presence at all,” laments Das, who was at the helm of protests over the Supreme Court’s ruling on Section 377 in 2013.

What is heartening, though, admits Das, is that young filmmakers, from mainstream and regional cinema alike, are exploring varied topics and telling stories that are honest and true. It can, perhaps, be pegged to growing dialogue on social media. Das credits it for “democratizing people’s voices”. One can’t help but wonder how a film like Fire might have fared in today’s times of hash tags and tweets.

Das is also heartened by the public discussions and debates that are gaining momentum and helping boost the cause for equal rights. “The ultimate aim is to ensure everybody has the space and right to be who they are,” Das says. She signs off on a hopeful note wishing for a country where people are “progressive and mature enough to give people space and right to love each other”.