IOC's Gender Stance
‘Insensitive And Harmful’ To Athletes
Indian sprinter Dutee Chand back in limbo as IOC
recommends return of hyperandrogenism rules.
By: Kerry Gillespie Sports reporter, Feb 23 2016
 |
| GRAHAM CROUCH / THE
NEW YORK TIMES |
Dutee Chand wants to
run with the body she was born with. The young sprinter from India fought for
that right all the way to the international Court of Arbitration for Sport.
She thought she had
won last July when the court suspended the athletics governing body’s gender
test and declared her eligible to compete.
Now, she’s not so
sure.
The International
Olympic Committee has released recommendations that, once again, raise
questions about whether Chand and women like her, whose bodies naturally
produce high levels of testosterone, will be allowed to compete at the Rio
Olympics this summer.
Chand’s team of
advocates, which includes Canadian and American experts, are now taking on the
IOC and what they see as an “insensitive and harmful attack on women with
hyperandrogenism.”
“We call on the IOC
to commit to publicly respect the (court’s) decision and declare that it will
not introduce hyperandrogenism regulations for the upcoming Rio Olympic Games,”
states the letter sent to IOC president Thomas Bach on Monday.
It was signed by
Bruce Kidd, a Toronto sport policy advisor, Katrina Karkazis, a Stanford
University bioethicist and Payoshni Mitra, the university researcher who first
approached Chand about fighting her case, and the rule itself, in court.
A woman who injects
testosterone, or a man for that matter, will generally get an athletic benefit
from it. That’s why it’s a banned performance-enhancing drug.
But, as Chand’s
pro-bono lawyer, James Bunting, a sports law expert at Toronto’s Davies Ward
Phillips & Vineberg, was able to show, the science is far less clear in the
case of hyperandrogenism.
The court stated
that it was not satisfied that the degree of advantage is any greater than
other variables that determine sporting excellence, ranging from good genes to
proper nutrition, coaching and training.
The court determined
that the policy of the international governing body for athletics, the IAAF,
which set a line in the sand for testosterone — above 10 nano moles per liter
and women were considered male and barred from competition until they had
surgery or hormone therapy to reduce their levels — was discriminatory and
lacked scientific evidence.
It gave them two
years to provide scientific proof for the rule and set it aside for the time
being.
The IOC’s
hyperandrogenism recommendations, released publicly in late January as part of
an update to its guidelines for transgendered athletes, didn’t address the
scientific or ethical arguments. But it urged the IAAF and other sport
organizations to return to the court “with arguments and evidence to support
the reinstatement of its hyperandrogenism rules.”
Could that happen
before Rio? And, if not, will the IOC decide to implement rules of its own
ahead of the 2016 Games?
No one knows and
that leaves Chand back in limbo.
“Last summer when
the sports court declared me eligible to compete and suspended the IAAF
regulations, I felt like a weight had been lifted from my shoulders. I could
finally go back to focusing on my training with Olympic qualification in mind,”
the 20-year-old said in a statement.
“But now the stress
and anxiety has returned.”
The IOC and IAAF
could not be reached in time for deadline.
For Chand, this saga
began in 2014 when she was suddenly pulled from the team heading to the Glasgow
Commonwealth Games after being singled out for gender testing in India because
her body appeared “masculine.”
The IOC’s statement
“raises the possibility of the exact same thing happening again,” Karkazis
said.
Beyond the
uncertainty for athletes like Chand, who do not want to undergo unnecessary
treatments to alter the body they were born with, the IOC’s other
recommendation is just as disappointing, she said.
“To avoid
discrimination, if not eligible for female competition the athlete should be
eligible to compete in male competition,” it states.
“It’s completely
untrue,” Karkazis said.
“Not only would these
women not qualify in the men’s categories because they’re not pulling in men’s
times but their identity and legal papers don’t say anything of the sort. This
is horrible language that women can just go compete as men — it’s so
degrading.”
Last weekend, Chand
won a bronze medal in the 60-metre sprint at the Asian Indoor Athletics
Championships and, in the heats; she set an Indian national record with her
time of 7.28 seconds. That ranks as the 51st fastest time in the world for
women this year and it’s nowhere in the men’s field.
Chand’s supporters
believe that the attempts of sport bodies to determine who is a man and who is
a woman based on something as narrow as testosterone levels, with tests
triggered by how “masculine” women look, is little better than the naked
parades some athletes were forced to endure in the 1960s.
"An investigation can be triggered because of how someone looks," Karkazis said. " This affects all women."
Source: http://www.thestar.com/sports/amateur/2016/02/23/iocs-stand-on-masculine-women-insensitive-and-harmful.html