Wednesday, April 16, 2014

Transletter

Supreme Court Recognizes Third Gender, Glimmer of Hope For Gays


By Utkarsh Anand | New Delhi | 16 April 2014

Supreme Court Tuesday granted constitutional recognition to transgender as a third gender and also gave them the right to have family.

In a historic judgment that put personal autonomy and right of choice on par with human dignity, the Supreme Court Tuesday granted constitutional recognition to transgender as a third gender and also gave them the right to have family.
The court directed the government to treat transgender as a socially and educationally backward class, entitled to quotas like OBCs in educational institutions and for public appointments.
A bench of Justices K S Radhakrishnan and A K Sikri held that transgender, as a distinct “third gender” category, will have all rights under the law, including the right to marry each other, adopt, divorce, succession, inheritance and also to claim benefits under welfare programmes such as MNREGA.
“We hold that values of privacy, self-identity, autonomy and personal integrity are fundamental rights guaranteed to members of the transgender community under Article 19(1)(a) of the constitution of India and the state is bound to protect and recognize those rights,” the court said.

Maintaining that “self-defined sexual orientation and gender identity is integral to their personality,” the bench asked authorities to frame social welfare schemes and intensive health care programmes for transgender, after underlining that an estimated 23.5 million men have sex with men (MSM) in India.
The bench gave the Centre, states and union territories six months to implement its judgment.
It noted that since transgender in India were neither male nor female, treating them as any of these categories was “denial of their constitutional rights and social justice”. The court said “moral failure lies in the society’s unwillingness” to embrace such gender identities and expressions…”a mindset which we have to change” in the wake of “new social needs”.
The bench said the discrimination faced by transgender, also known as Hijras, eunuchs, Kothis, Aravanis, Jogappas, Shiv-Shakthis, among others, was “unimaginable” and their rights had to be protected, “irrespective of chromosomal sex, genitals, assigned birth sex, or implied gender role” to ensure a dignified life for them.

It said a psychological test and not a biological test has to be used to identify transgender and by recognizing them as a third category, the SC was “only bridging the gap between the law and the life”. The court added that any insistence to undergo a sex re-assignment surgery was “immoral and illegal”.
Significantly, the verdict also opens a window of hope for the other three categories of what is called the LGBT community, comprising lesbians, gays, bisexuals and transgender.
Four months ago, another SC bench had turned the clock back on homosexuals by withdrawing the legal protection granted to them by the Delhi High Court in 2009. The high court had decriminalized gay sex by holding that Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code, by criminalizing consensual sexual acts of adults in private, violated the principles of equality and non-discrimination in the constitution.
Under Section 377, voluntary “carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal,” is punishable with imprisonment from 10 years to life.
Withdrawing the legal protection to what it called a “minuscule fraction of the country’s population,” the SC had ruled that Section 377 will continue making gay sex – “irrespective of age and consent” – a crime and also rejected the argument on discrimination against this class.

However, Monday’s verdict asserted that any “discrimination on the ground of sexual orientation or gender identity” impaired equality before the law and hence violated Article 14 of the Constitution.
“Each person’s self-defined sexual orientation and gender identity is integral to their personality and is one of the most basic aspects of self-determination, dignity and freedom,” the bench said.
It emphasized that a constitutional court cannot be a mute spectator when these rights are violated and it is rather expected to safeguard them, acknowledging the pulse and feeling of that community, “though a minority”.
The court also pointed out that the term “transgender” will include gay, lesbian and bisexual. But it stopped going further on this by saying: “While dealing with the present issue we are not concerned with this aforesaid wider meaning of the expression transgender.”
A curative petition against the re-criminalization of gay sex is likely to be listed in the SC soon and Monday’s judgment is expected to come handy for legal arguments since sexual activity, including carnal intercourse and oral sex, among transgender is no more a crime after their identification as a third gender while it remains a crime for lesbians, gays and bisexuals.
Senior advocate Anand Grover, who represents the LGBT community in the fight against Section 377, told The Indian Express that he was encouraged by the judgment stressing that non-discrimination due to the “sexual orientation” of a person violated human rights. The verdict on transgender came on a PIL by the National Legal Services Authority, which asked for ending social, political and cultural ostracism of transender by granting them legal status of a third and equal sex.

SOURCE: http://indianexpress.com/article/india/india-others/sc-recognises-third-gender-glimmer-of-hope-for-gays/

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Transletter

Coming Out Of The Closet, Daring Orthodoxy

By Deepthy Sreenivasan

ENS - 29th July 2013

Thiruvananthapuram: Rappai, 36, was born and brought up like a man in Koyilandy. But, he claims to be married to a man for the past 16 years . Ask him for any proof and he would proudly flaunt his long Gold ‘Thali’ (the auspicious chain worn by married women). Rappai, fondly known as Bhavana, is one of the homosexual male belonging to the sexual minority MSM (Men having Sex with Men) community in Kozhikode district who had the gumption to come out in the open and admit his sexual orientation.
 
It could come as a shock to the average orthodox communities of Kerala that there are approximately 20,000 men identified under MSM community throughout the State by The Kerala State Aids Control Society. “Thise number is just the tip of the iceberg,” says Sanjesh, Project Director of Pehchan at Malabar Cultural Forum, an organisation that functions to support sexual minority group in Kozhikode. Rappai’s story is not an isolated one. A mind boggling number of men in the State are leading a double life.

For obvious reasons Gay,transgender,transexual and Eunuchs are hardly acknowledged as different groups and the term ‘MSM’ is non-existent in our society. The Kerala State Aids Control Society ( KSACS) has 14 target intervention programmes that addresses the MSM community. Dennis Joseph, Joint Director, Kerala State Aids Control Society explained “The intervention programmes started ten years ago. We have identified 20,317 men over the past five years. Every year there is a five to ten percent increase in the number of people who come out as homosexual.”
 
MSM is categorised as Kothi, Panthi, Double Decker and Transgender. This categorisation is based on the various sexual behavior of self identified homosexual men. As per records of Malabar Cultural forum 1,750 homosexual men have registered with the organisation in Kozhikode and Wayanad with 400 Kothis, 550 transgenders and 800 double deckers. 2,996 homosexual males have registered in Malappuram with 420 transgenders, 604 kothis and 1,972 double deckers.
 
Navas who heads an organisation called Marvel since 2011 at Ernakulam said that 550 homosexual men have registered with them. Most of them who registered with the organisation are between the age group of 18-25. “There are more than 300 people yet to register. Most of them are not prepared to come out in the open.” He went on to add “ when we opened this organisation, it was women who created more ruckus than men.” Snehatheeram an organisation based at Kannur registered in 2007 has close to 1,600 registrations between the age group of 20 to 60 since then. Amongst them 16 are HIV +ve. Shyam who heads an organisation named Voice at Thrissur stated that they have identified 1,500 homosexual men. There are organisations functioning in Pathanamthitta, Kollam,Trivandrum and Palakkad as well.
 
Most of the men who have registered claim that they have undergone some degree of sexual abuse as children before they came to terms with their sexual orientation. Ali who is known as Aleena in the group said he had undergone physical molestation at the hands of his two close relatives before he had turned 10 years old. He claims that the incident changed his life, after which he accepted that he was more attracted to men than women. Some others state that they knew their orientation was different by the time they were 10 years old but it was only after a physical molestation that they decided to accept it completely. Shaji who calls himself Sajida said he was molested by a relative when he was just 12 years old. Shaji was quite sure about his sexual orientation by then and pointed out that this molestation only confirmed his doubts.
 
Adding to their constant ant fight for acceptance in the society, is the hostile behavior meted out to them by police officials. “Most men in and around our area know of our sexual orientation. They take advantage of it and try to physically hurt us. When we approach the police their response is very cold and we are humiliated and teased over our sexual orientation. Surprisingly many of these policemen are our clients,” says a member of the community.
 
Even two to three years back most of the homosexual men used to turn to prostitution for a living after coming out. This scenario is changing. Many of the men have other jobs. Somehow people have begun to accept us. Which is why, many men are daring to come out of their closets, nowadays,” says Sanjesh.
 

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Transletter

Transgender Ex-SEAL Kristin Beck Now Living As A Woman

05 June 13 via news.com.au

A RETIRED US Navy SEAL has revealed she is now living life as a woman.

Kristen Beck, formerly Chris, spent twenty years as a member of the elite SEALs, but realised after leaving that she wanted to become a woman, US ABC News reports.
 
Beck tells her story, saying she suppressed her sexuality and gender identity for decades while in the armed forces, in her new book Warrior Princess.
 
"Chris really wanted to be a girl and felt that she was a girl and consolidated that identity very early on in childhood," co-author Anne Speckhard told ABC News.

She kept her secret while undergoing the intense SEAL training and while serving on battlefields around the world, even growing a bushy beard. He wanted to live as a woman during this time, but felt he couldn’t while serving as a SEAL, the book says.
 
"For years Chris had turned off his sexuality like a light switch and lived as a warrior, consumed with the battle - living basically asexual," the book says.

But after she left in 2011, it "seemed the right time to go for it - to make his body match his identity - or at least start by dressing like a woman in his regular life."

Beck announced her decision in a dramatic online post, promising "no more disguises" and later venturing out to gay bars as a woman. She is undergoing hormone therapy ahead of sexual reassignment surgery, has grown long hair and often wears dresses, Speckhard said.

Source: http://www.news.com.au/lifestyle/relationships/transgender-ex-seal-kristin-beck-now-living-as-a-woman/story-fnet09p2-1226657410826#ixzz2ZqImOGr5

Wednesday, May 22, 2013

Transletter

Indian-Origin Transsexual Avoids Caning, Gets 14-Month Jail
 
PTI May 18, 2013
 
SINGAPORE: A Singaporean of Indian-origin, who underwent a sex change operation, was spared the cane but sentenced to 14-month jail for damaging property and harassing a debtor.
 
21-year-old transsexual Benitha, formerly known as Kavi Raj Tamaraselvan, was sent to the women jail for her role in setting fire to the door of an apartment in the Ang Mo Kio public housing estate, The Straits Times reported on Saturday.
 
Male offenders would normally receive between three and six strokes of the cane for each such offence, but Benitha had undergone sex change in Thailand six months before committing the offence.
 
District judge Hamidah Ibrahim said that since Benitha is now a woman there would not be no caning.
 
Benitha wore a tight-fitting red top in court. Pleading for leniency, defence counsel Rajan Supramaniam said that Banitha had fallen under the "corrupting influence" of Geevanraj Balraj, one of her two accomplices and who had promised to marry her.
 
Geenvanraj, 20, was sentenced last November to reformative training for between 1-1/2 years and three years. Benitha's other accomplice was a 15-year-old boy, who can not be named for being a minor but was placed on probation for two years.
 
The trio were arrested on September 14 last year for scribing graffiti and setting fire to the door of the apartment. They used petrol, which Geevanraj had stolen from a motorcycle in a carpark.
 
Benitha took pictures of the graffiti and recorded the fire with a mobile phone to show an unlicensed moneylender, who has been identified only as Alex. Unemployed Geevanraj ran into financial difficulties after he suffered 4000 dollars losses on football bets.
 
To pay the debts, he started working with Alex in September last year, receiving 200 dollars for each harassment job, which involved damaging properties of others who owe money to the unlicensed moneylender. The trio also committed two similar offences two days before their arrests and defaced a car by scribbling graffiti on its bonnet.
 
The court took these three offences into consideration when sentencing Benitha, who could have been jailed up to five years and fined between 5,000 and 50,000 dollars. Her two accomplices were also spared the cane because of their young age, according to the report.
 
Loan shark runners were commonly used by unlicensed moneylenders to harassing indebted people by setting house doors on fire and spreading graffiti to shame and insult them.
 

Monday, March 18, 2013

Transletter

I Always Knew I Was Different
 
By: Racheal Mcgonigal
 
As a sex change transsexual female nearing 60 years old, I am often asked what it is like to come out as a transsexual and why I waited until I was 49.
 
Even some transsexuals who were out in the 1960s and 1970s can't understand why so late. We are all individuals and what was right for you, wasn't necessarily right for others or me. In the 60s and 70s, prostitution and homosexuality were not legal and very much frowned upon. Christianity played an enormous part in everyday life. I can even remember when a divorce case between a local husband and wife ran for five days and was the major story of the day in the local paper.
 
I lived in rural Hawke's Bay - a country community. Society back then wasn't as open nor as accepting as now. The world ran by what society deemed right. Men were bread winners and the women ran the house. At seven years old, I knew I was different but not how. When Mum and Dad went to town, I could dress and watch Lassie or Tin Tin on TV.
 
For high school, I was sent to a Presbyterian Private Boys Boarding school. I remember when two third formers were caught together one night in the drying room and beaten up for being 'homos'. They were humiliated and never lost the stigma.
 
I was trained by society and religion that I was a male and what was expected of a male. I was a prop in the 1st XV for three years and became a Prefect then Head Prefect. I even read sermons in church and made speeches and became the chairman of committees and clubs.
 
But I was different. Who could I talk to and ask what this was? I constantly thought about it, trying to work it out. There was no internet, only libraries, but what would I look up? I didn't know where to begin and life went on, it was all about university, parties and even girlfriends. I always got the good lookers but was it just their looks and clothes that attracted me?
 
I tried to talk to the university doctor one day and he laughed and told me to ''grow a beard and you will feel more manly''. Having been laughed at I was really not keen to go through that again. Time went by and still, I questioned who I was and experimented. It made me worry and stress a lot, but I felt like I had to conform to Christian values and the moral expectations of a man.
 
I bought a farm, fell in love, married and had children. I had male responsibility a plenty. My family and parents depended upon me. But I felt comfortable and was only at ease when I was able to be me, in a dress and watching TV.
 
The fear of losing all, humiliated, losing those I loved and losing everything was possible. But I came to realise, I wasn't the 'me' I had been trained to be. I was actually Racheal. In my life, people use to ask, why I found it hard to smile and laugh as others did.
 
I guess constant stress, fear, worry, and concern are the answers, but a look through my pictorial diary will show you Racheal smiles so much now.
 

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Transletter

Mixed Martial Arts Fighter Fallon Fox Comes Out As Trans

By: Jessica Wakeman
After six years of competitive MMA (mixed martial arts) fighting as a woman, Fallon Fox has come out of the closet — against her wishes — as trans.

In an interview with OutSports on Tuesday, Fox explained how she was born into a male body, but never felt right. Ten years ago, she told her parents that she felt like she was born inside the wrong body. Her father pressured her into seeing a so-called “gay conversion therapist,” who insisted that Fallon was a gay man who was just confused. Fallon’s mother rejected her entirely; in the past two years, she hasn’t spoken to either parent.

But Fallon knew in her heart what her identity is: Fox began hormone therapy 10 years ago — after dropping the anti-gay therapy — and got gender reassignment surgery six years ago. She even has a driver’s license identifying her as a female. After her surgery, she took up MMA fighting. She praised the support of those close to her for their support.

As for any physical advantages — size, testosterone — she might have had from being born in a man’s body, Fox said they’ve all likely been erased by 10 years’ worth of hormone therapy. “I’m technically, legally, physically female. Everything about me is female,” she told OutSports. She calls her transition the best thing she’s ever done in her entire life.

That doesn’t mean, however, that Fox wanted to be “out.” When a reporter called her on Saturday night asking about her gender, Fox felt a pit in her stomach knowing that she would soon be forced to make her private life public. Her reluctance has come from fear of transphobia, of course, as well as the professional desire to be treated unquestionably as a “woman,” not treated as a “trans woman” or just “trans.” Fox told Out Sports she is hoping the Champion Fighting Alliance won’t forbid her from competition and hopes one day to compete in the Olympics. She is scheduled to fight in Florida in April, but her license is being reviewed by a state regulatory agency now that she’s been revealed as trans.

OutSports also has a short, five-minute film interview with Fallon Fox, which shows her to be both thoughtful and conflicted about the complications of her life. It really sucks that she was forced out of the closet against her will and that her family-of-birth couldn’t get over themselves. Still, her story is as inspiring and she seems really courageous and rad. I wish her the best of luck in her career.
 
Source: http://www.thefrisky.com/2013-03-07/mixed-martial-arts-fighter-fallon-fox-comes-out-as-trans/

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Transletter

Families of Lesbian And Gay Individuals Heard In New Film

By: Emrah GülerANKARA - Hürriyet Daily News

The representation of gays and lesbians in Turkey is problematic, transsexual individuals even more so. A recent movie, ‘Benim Çocuğum’ (My Child), funded through crowd sourcing, might be a big step toward changing that

It has been quite the month in the media for the visibility of LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual) communities in Turkey, even more for the families of LGBT individuals. While gay men (and to some degree, lesbians) are more and more becoming the darlings of pop culture (albeit laced with stereotypes), the representation of and news coverage regarding transsexual women continue under an awful light.
Transsexual women are the actors of freak shows, as far as the mass media is concerned. As for transsexual men, they are just invisible. Unless, of course, you’re the sex-changing son of Cher. This all took a different turn in the last couple of weeks, as new openings for LGBT individuals, openings that never before found a place in the mass media, blossomed as full-fledged, real stories.
A group of transsexual men – one a public figure – their mothers and fathers, as well as the families of certain other LGBT individuals, took center stage in a flow of coverage in the mass, alternative and social media.

Those following the LGBT civil initiatives and groups in Turkey were already aware of a new documentary in the making for the last two years, a production that hoped to raise money through the crowd-sourcing web site, Indiegogo. The name of the film was “Benim Çocuğum” (My Child), and a few sentences were enough to shed light on the film. “Parents of LGBT’s in Turkey speak out! What happens when your child comes out to you? A feature documentary about five mothers and two fathers of LGBT’s in Istanbul.”

“My Child” finally completed its journey from a hopeful pre-production to a moving documentary that made its debut in the recent !f Istanbul International Independent Film Festival. The documentary, directed by filmmaker and academic Can Candan, puts the families of LGBT individuals in the spotlight for the first time. The first half of the movie is a collection of intimate interviews with parents, as their quivering voices alternate in recalling the journeys their children and they themselves had to go through.

Seven Advocates For LİSTAG
One mother remembers how she had to hide her pain when buying the son she had given birth to her first bra. Another recalls the moment she finally acknowledged that her son’s best friend was actually his boyfriend. One father tells of the struggles he had to endure throughout his daughter’s journey from chronic depression and anorexia t o finally coming out.

The documentary ‘My Child’ is directed by
filmmaker and academic Can Candan.
“Coming out” is a term hovering throughout the documentary. But more than the children’s coming out, it is the parents’ coming out that take up most of the screen time. As one mother told the audience in the film’s Ankara premiere last week, “There is the process of families’ coming out just as there is the children’s. We are the seven people who are ready to be advocates, who are ready to be visible.”
These seven parents, whose troubled faces light up the screen, are, as one mother puts it, “the tip of the iceberg,” the iceberg that is LİSTAG, Families of LGBT in Istanbul, a civil initiative that took off in 2008. Their stories are of fear, despair, denial, shame, acceptance and – to these lucky families – rebirth.
 
The families in LİSTAG take one of their major missions as guiding families in their harrowing and very difficult journey in a homophobic and transphobic society. The second half of the film features scenes from their monthly dinner, the new and the old coming together, and later their preparations for the upcoming Gay Pride events in Istanbul. One mother talks of how, after a period of nonchalance, it dawned on her that she had become a true activist.

The World Listens To Mothers

These parents, in fact, redefine activism through unconditional love and acceptance. One scene shows the LİSTAG group watching themselves in Parliament talking about their children to TV cameras, some great feat after the public statement made by Selma Aliye Kavaf, the Turkish State Minister Responsible for Women and Family, in which she said, “I believe homosexuality is a biological disorder, a disease. It needs to be treated.”

The hard work the group has been doing, along with the push the film has been giving, seems to have begun to pay off. Among the audience in the Ankara premiere were three parliamentarians from the main opposition party, Republican People’s Party (CHP). One of them, Binnaz Toprak, made her feelings heard after the screening: “You are the bravest people in the world. This film should be screened in parliament, too. I promise to do my best for this to happen.”

The film had helped LİSTAG reach out to families throughout Turkey. “When ‘My Child’ was screened recently in the southeastern city of Diyarbakır as part of !f İstanbul,” one of the parents said, “the screening venue was filled with families.” Coinciding with the film’s surprisingly positive coverage in the media was another bomb, when Ayşe Arman, the doyenne of groundbreaking interviews, last week interviewed for daily Hürriyet an actor who underwent gender reassignment surgery from female to male.

The heart-to-heart interview generally received positive feedback, with the expected backlash, some news stories embellishing the reaction to the interview with supposed death threats and implications that Rüzgar Erkoçlar’s family was far from supportive. Erkoçlar’s mother was quick to answer, showcasing a reaction very much like the parents in “My Child.” “Rüzgar did not do anything bad. We have always supported him. However, some of the news has damaged us a lot,” told Sema Erkoçlar of Hürriyet. “Rüzgar never received death threats. But some people are making that up.” When mothers speak up, the world listens. These courageous mothers know their power and are not afraid to use it for a better world.